Connect With Us Connect With Us Newsletter Connect with us
 

Cheap Eats NYC: $5 Lunch in the West Village

In this city, it’s easy to drop $15 on a sandwich and a soda without even realizing it — but you don’t have to pony up nearly that much for a tasty midday meal, as we will explore in this ongoing penny-pinching series, $5 Lunch. To start things off, we’re visiting the beautiful West Village known for its delicious (but not usually cheap) restaurants. Still, we’ve uncovered four places to get lunch for $5 or under, from old-school pizza to Indian-style wrap sandwiches.

 

Murray's Bagels

A bacon, egg and cheese bagel at Murray’s Bagels (Photo: Courtesy of Murray’s Bagels)

Thelewala
On an NYU-area strip filled with unexciting eateries, Thelewala stands out for its menu of Indian street food-inspired eats. The Nizami rolls — soft, griddled paratha wrapped around a filling of your choice – are the real draw and both the achari aloo tikka roll, stuffed with eggs and red onions, and the okra roll are $5 or under. And if you decide to go carnivore with the spiced chicken roll, it’s only fifty cents more. 112 Macdougal St., 212-614-9100, thelewalanyc.com

Bleecker Street Pizza
This old-school slice joint is what we wish for every corner — a reliable New York-style pizzeria with tons of delicious options and super-fast service. While you can’t go wrong with any of its slices, the Nonna Maria is a specialty here, with generous pools of fresh mozzarella, tangy marinara sauce and fresh basil too for just $3.50 a slice. 69 Seventh Ave. S., 212-924-4466, bleekerstreetpizza.net

Murray’s Bagels
Some folks say egg sandwiches are only for breakfast, but we find that rather unimaginative. Egg and cheese on a bagel is a classic New York meal, and at Murray’s Bagel, one of Manhattan’s better bagelries, it’s still $4.50 (high rollers can add bacon or ham for just another dollar). Another alternative: a bagel with their Nova (lox) cream cheese spread for $4.95. Great rugelach for dessert, too. 500 Sixth Ave., 212-482-2830, murraysbagels.com

Mamoun’s
Hands-down, the best falafel in the West Village is at Taim, but it’ll cost you (a still wallet-friendly) six bucks. For also-tasty falafel on the cheap, head to the original location of perennial favorite Mamoun’s, where you can get a falafel-stuffed pita for just $3 — we won’t judge if you order two. 119 Macdougal St., 212-674-8685, mamouns.com

Check out more cheap eats in Chinatown, the West Village, East Village, Lower East Side, Union Square Williamsburg and around town.

Popular Buys

Popular Reads

Sign Up For
Special Offers!
Close