Docked “at the end of the strip” near its Fish Box forerunner, this “casual” City Islander dispenses “down-to-earth” “fried seafood” and “lots of it” at a “nice price”; it’s a standard “hang in the summer”, where you should expect “very crowded” conditions.
This Bronx seafood joint (a spinoff of the classic Sammy's Fish Box) offers epic portions of fresh seafood. First-time visitors to City Island may be surprised to find a fishing village vibe within the city limits and restaurants that would fit right in on Cape Cod. Sammy's moderately priced menu includes New England clam chowder, Maine lobsters, platters of fried whole bellies, broiled fish fillets, steaks for landlubbers and a children's menu. There are also a few Latin dishes like arroz con pollo and paella left over from the restaurant's previous identity as Tito Puente's. Locals and day-trippers stretch out in cushioned booths and at large tables in the bustling dining room year-round; in warm weather, there's sidewalk seating (though, sadly, no water view). Visitors on tight schedules should note that getting from Midtown to City Island on public transit takes well over an hour.
6 to Pelham Bay Park, then B-29 bus to City Island Ave. – Rochelle St.
What to tell a cabbie From most points in the city, a taxi ride to City Island will be expensive. Consider taking public transit or asking the staff at your hotel to arrange a fixed fare with a car service.
Where restaurant insiders are eating now
Just five or six years ago, the notion of great eating in Bushwick was a completely foreign one. In fact, for most New Yorkers, the notion of even visiting Bushwick was also foreign.Read more »
New York has plenty of the same chains you’d see in any other American metropolis.Read more »
It’s the annual October non-surprise: a ton of new restaurants open during NYC’s favorite dining monthRead more »
We like the way Mexicans think. Once a year, instead of mawkishly mourning the dead, they honor the lives of those who have passed with a feast. Though Day of the Dead is officially celebrated November 1-2, at 14 year-old La PalapaRead more »
We are currently searching our extensive restaurant listings.