Little Italy, once the epicenter of all things authentically Italian in New York, is now more of a historical district than an area occupied by Italian-Americans. What hasn’t changed, however, is the abundance of bona fide Italian-inspired pizzerias that have withstood the test of time. Searching for the best pizza in Little Italy NYC is no small feat, so read on to find out which shops are worth the visit!
Zia Maria Little Italy
Zia Maria offers patrons an unrivaled dining experience in the heart of Little Italy. The homemade cuisine pairs well with a fully stocked, top-shelf alcohol selection and modern aesthetic. Pizzas at Zia Maria are only crafted with the finest and freshest ingredients, with fan favorites like the margherita and prosciutto style pies making for a mouthwatering meal. Service is friendly and attentive, the icing on the cake for a reasonably-priced, unforgettable trip that makes you feel like you’re really in Naples.
Pep’s on Grand
Quality. Authenticity. Consistency. These are the traits Pep’s on Grand strives to put forward in all that they do. Southern Italian charm is this hidden gem’s specialty, and it shines through, particularly in the warm greetings and personable staff catering to you as soon as you walk through the doors. Every pizza is truly exceptional and cooked to perfection with crispy thin crust, evenly melted cheese and locally sourced toppings rounding things off. Their top-tier cocktail selection also doesn’t hurt, and the Espresso Martini is a fan favorite you’ll want to savor with each sip.
Manero’s Of Mulberry
If you’re in the mood for a quick service, no-nonsense pizzeria with affordable prices then stop by this intimate establishment in the Southern portion of Little Italy. Manero’s interior is inspired by the movie Saturday Night Fever, and stepping inside can make you feel like you’ve traveled back in time five decades. You’ll be standing up during your visit but it’s entirely worth it, a casual slice and soda here is more than enough to satisfy your hunger. Manero’s of Mulberry has perfected that blend of traditional Italian and classic New York styles to provide artisanal fare even the strictest pizza connoisseur will enjoy.
Gelso & Grand
This Michelin Star restaurant offers a tight-knit and inviting atmosphere to customers, infusing classic and modern dining into one outstanding, culinary experience. The restaurant’s name is a reference to its southern European roots, as “Gelso” means Mulberry in Italian, apt as it is the cross street with Grand. Gelso & Grand sports a rustic vibe perfect for unwinding with a glass of wine and one of their signature, wood-fired pizzas. The menu changes seasonally, but flavorful staples such as the truffle mushroom pie and sausage with broccoli rabe are on the menu right now, so don’t miss out!
Margherita NYC specializes in making basic Italian dishes with a unique style and flair. All ingredients are either imported from Italy or locally sourced which elevates the quality of the cuisine. The pizzas here are made with care and taste so fresh you won’t believe it unless you try it for yourself. Options such as the Diavola, a pie smothered with spicy cured salame and mixed with fresh basil, tomato sauce, and mozzarella, will leave you wanting more. With over a dozen different offerings- including gluten-free and vegan-friendly options-, a pizza from Margherita NYC is sure to be a memorable experience!
This family-owned and operated staple of Little Italy has been in business for 104 years, having gotten its start when the patriarch Gregorio Garofalo emigrated from Puglia, Italy to pursue his vision of making great food. Over the centuries, Puglia Ristorante has blossomed into a legendary hotspot that is perfect for commemorating joyous occasions with phenomenal Italian dishes. The Puglia Special, a penne alla vodka pizza complemented with Al dente pasta and soft, chewy, crispy crust is cooked to perfection in an iconic brick oven. Perfection reigns supreme at Puglia and it really shows in everything they have to offer.